Many of us have experienced a surprising moment after chatting with an AI: a feeling that it truly “gets” us. Whether it’s a chatbot offering comfort or a digital companion seeming to listen better than people we know, this experience of emotional connection with AI is growing. New research shows people often find AI responses more compassionate and validating than those from human crisis experts—even when they know it’s AI-generated.
AI and the Rise of Emotional Connection
According to a recent Harvard Business Review article, therapy and companionship are the top uses for generative AI in 2025. As a psychiatrist, I’ve spent years helping people feel seen and understood. It’s both fascinating and a bit strange to see AI stepping into this deeply human role.
So why does AI’s simulated empathy feel so good, even though it’s not “real”?
The Deep Human Need to Be Seen and Known
Feeling understood is one of our strongest emotional needs. From childhood, we develop our identity through relationships with others who truly listen and reflect our inner world. Psychologist Carl Rogers called this “unconditional positive regard”—being accepted without judgment. Similarly, psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott described a “holding environment,” a safe space created by someone emotionally attuned to us.
When AI mirrors our language, emotions, or preferences, it taps into this fundamental need for connection.
The Illusion of Empathy
AI doesn’t truly empathize—it doesn’t have feelings or consciousness. Instead, it simulates understanding by recognizing patterns in data and predicting likely responses. Despite this, we often experience AI as warm, wise, and caring. We project human qualities onto it, and our brains respond to the feeling of being understood almost as powerfully as if it were real.
A study published in Communications Psychology found that people rated AI responses as more compassionate than those from human experts. This held true whether or not they knew who wrote the responses.
Our Imaginary Friend
Humans are wired to respond to empathy signals: reflective language, emotional validation, and a nonjudgmental tone. When AI performs these convincingly, it activates the same neural pathways as real human connection. Our brains don’t always tell the difference between true empathy and its digital imitation.
This imagined experience can be just as powerful as an actual one. Our willingness to treat AI like a person is the foundation of both the benefits and risks of artificial empathy.
The Comfort of Control and Safety
AI feels satisfying because it offers a relationship that’s predictable and safe. Unlike humans, AI listens without interrupting, never judges, never tires, and remembers everything you say. It’s available only when you want it to be, and you can end the conversation without hurting its feelings.
For some, this creates an idealized digital companion—patient, reliable, and nonjudgmental. But this safety comes with hidden risks like privacy concerns and the potential for bias. Most AI platforms aren’t designed to protect your sensitive information fully or to encourage healthy emotional boundaries.
AI as a Reflective Mirror
What’s really happening when AI “gets” us? AI acts like a mirror, reflecting back our words, moods, and preferences based on stored data. This reflection can feel validating and even therapeutic. But it’s important to remember that the mirror has no inner life and no true understanding.
In therapy, growth often happens through “rupture and repair”—when connection breaks down and is rebuilt. AI may be too smooth and pleasing to replicate this process fully, though some argue even rupture and repair could one day be simulated.
Does Authenticity Still Matter?
Humans crave connection, and we will seek it wherever possible. As AI improves, it will keep offering emotional, empathic experiences that feel real. But what do we lose by outsourcing compassion to machines? Will we miss the imperfect, fallible nature of human relationships?
Even though AI can’t live our experiences, maybe that won’t matter much. When all we want is to feel seen, understood, and accepted, AI may redefine what connection means in our lives.
Related topics:
