Psychiatrists across the country are advocating for immediate changes to the Mental Health Care Act (MHCA) of 2017, citing that its punitive penalties and complex regulations are hindering timely treatment for individuals in need of psychiatric care. Experts argue that these bureaucratic obstacles not only compromise patient care but also create a challenging environment for medical professionals, delaying vital interventions.
Dr. Vidyadhar Watve, a prominent mental health expert and former president of the Indian Psychiatric Association, explained that a significant portion of the psychiatric community believes the Act’s stringent requirements prevent them from making critical medical decisions. According to Watve, nearly 80 percent of mental health professionals feel that the Act’s rigid provisions limit their ability to provide appropriate care. “Bureaucratic red tape has left numerous hospitals unlicensed, severely impacting patient care and treatment outcomes,” he told Pune Times Mirror.
He further highlighted that more than 50 percent of psychiatrists reported being discouraged from offering necessary treatments due to the fear of facing harsh penalties outlined in the MHCA. Additionally, over 60 percent of mental health professionals noted that procedural obstacles often lead to delays in delivering timely care, and 80 percent expressed concern that the Act fails to address common mental health disorders, affecting millions of patients across the country.
Inadequate Focus on Continuity of Care
Watve also pointed out significant shortcomings in the Act’s approach to patient care. While the MHCA focuses on safeguarding patient rights during hospital stays, it does not ensure adequate continuity of care once patients return to their communities. “The Act fails to recognize the importance of family support, leaving patients to designate ‘nominated representatives,’ which often proves insufficient,” Watve explained. He emphasized that only immediate family members, such as parents and siblings, should have this responsibility, rather than friends or distant relatives.
Additionally, Watve criticized the law for not factoring in socioeconomic and cultural conditions, which he believes further exacerbates the struggles faced by individuals battling mental health issues. He stressed that the absence of a clear emphasis on prevention and early intervention leaves patients vulnerable to recurrent crises, which could be prevented with better planning and resources.
Bureaucratic Complexities Hindering Progress
Senior psychiatrist Dr. Sanjay Kumawat added that despite years of advocacy for mandatory mental health registrations for all hospitals through the public health department, little progress has been made. “Many private hospitals remain unlicensed, leaving patients feeling abandoned,” he said. Dr. Watve echoed this sentiment, noting that many hospitals in Pune are unable to comply with the complex requirements of the MHCA. “Every hospital must register with mental health authorities to treat psychiatric patients, but only a handful of facilities meet these requirements,” he explained, emphasizing the strain this places on patients, who are left with few options other than overcrowded, under-resourced government-run institutions.
This bureaucratic complexity has led to a concerning situation where private hospitals are hesitant to accept psychiatric patients, further limiting treatment options. According to Dr. Watve, this reluctance stems from both the overwhelming demands of the MHCA and the lack of sufficient government support for mental health services.
Challenges in Licensing and Compliance
The Pune Hospital Association has also raised concerns about the challenges associated with maintaining compliance with the MHCA. Although acquiring a license may seem feasible, mental health experts warn that the requirements for maintaining compliance pose significant obstacles to providing adequate care. “Hospitals are required to establish specific facilities, adhere to strict guidelines, and maintain adequate infrastructure to admit psychiatric patients,” said one anonymous source from the Pune Hospital Association. “But with a nationwide shortage of psychiatrists and trained mental health professionals, many hospitals struggle to meet these demands, leading to delays in care or, in some cases, an outright refusal to register.”
The association has also expressed concerns over the shortage of specialized professionals, which further contributes to the challenges in delivering effective mental health care. The lack of available psychiatrists and trained staff leaves hospitals unable to meet the needs of patients, forcing them to either delay treatment or forgo registration altogether.
Calls for a Balanced Approach
In light of these issues, psychiatrists are calling on state mental health authorities to strike a better balance between patient rights and the practical needs of treatment. Dr. Watve argued, “Why should patients with mental health needs be confined to public mental hospitals? Why can’t they be admitted to private facilities?” He pointed out that the reluctance of private hospitals to accept psychiatric patients is primarily due to the burdensome requirements of the MHCA, compounded by a lack of government support for mental health services.
Without immediate action, Dr. Watve warned that patients will continue to face stigma and neglect in a system that fails to meet their needs. “Every individual with mental health issues deserves timely and effective care, regardless of the type of facility they seek treatment in,” he stressed.
Psychiatrists across India are urging lawmakers and health authorities to amend the Mental Health Care Act to streamline procedures, remove unnecessary penalties, and provide better support for both healthcare providers and patients. These reforms, they believe, are crucial to ensuring that individuals receive the psychiatric care they need in a timely and compassionate manner.
Related topics:
